
Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa
Best for families or groups who want a larger resort with waterfront dining, on-site spa (Jala Spa) and more rooms/options.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa is a 4-star waterfront resort on Front Street that suits families and travelers who want marina views, on-site dining and a full-service spa. Duval Gardens at Southernmost Beach Resort is a 4-star, adults-only (21+) small property on Duval Street for travelers who want a compact, quiet stay steps from Key West attractions.
Updated

Best for families or groups who want a larger resort with waterfront dining, on-site spa (Jala Spa) and more rooms/options.

Best for adults seeking a quiet, intimate property on Duval Street with easy walking access to Key West attractions.
When Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa wins: Choose Hyatt Centric if you want a waterfront resort with on-site sea-to-table dining (Four Flamingos), a named spa (Jala Spa), family-friendly policies and more rooms and on-site facilities.
When Duval Gardens at Southernmost Beach Resort wins: Choose Duval Gardens if you prefer an adults-only stay right on Duval Street, a very small property with a simple, intimate setup and convenient walking access to beaches and local attractions.
Bottom line: Hyatt Centric is the fuller-service, family-friendly waterfront resort with more facilities; Duval Gardens is a compact adults-only option for travelers who prioritize location on Duval Street and a quieter small-property feel.
| Category | Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa | Duval Gardens at Southernmost Beach Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Larger waterfront resort with resort facilities and family focus | Small, adults-only inn-style property focused on location and quiet |
| Location (Old Town / Duval Street) | Waterfront on Front St, steps from Duval Street and Mallory Square | On Duval Street (1317 Duval St), in the heart of Key West attractions |
| Size / rooms | About 118–120 rooms across four floors | 12 rooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age is 18 for the lead guest | Adults-only property (guests under 18 not permitted) |
| Pools | One outdoor pool, cabanas, whirlpool; pool hours described sunrise–sundown | One outdoor pool with 24-hour pool access listed |
| Restaurants & bars | Four Flamingos (sea-to-table) + Blue Mojito Bar & Grill + Keys Coffee Cafecito | Not published |
| Spa & wellness | Jala Spa on site, 9:00 AM–7:00 PM; massage and body treatments | Health or beauty spa nearby (not confirmed on-site name) |
| Known for | Waterfront location, marina views, on-site sea-to-table dining and Jala Spa | Location steps from Duval Street and Florida Keys beaches; adults-only |
| Parking | Self-parking only (fee), EV charging available on site | Self parking (surcharge) onsite |
| Check-in / check-out | Check-in from 4:00 PM; check-out 11:00 AM | |
Hyatt Centric sits on Front Street along the Gulf of Mexico waterfront in Old Town Key West, minutes from Duval Street and Mallory Square.
Best if you want easy access to waterfront activities and a short walk to Old Town sights while staying on the marina.
Duval Gardens is located at 1317 Duval St in the heart of Key West’s main strip, putting restaurants and sights at your doorstep.
Choose Duval Gardens for a location-first stay if you want immediate access to Duval Street and nearby beaches.
Hyatt Centric offers a wide range of room types across about 118–120 rooms with many waterfront or balcony options.
Hyatt Centric suits families and groups who want multiple room types and balcony options.
Duval Gardens has a very small set of guest rooms and simple accommodations focused on a quieter stay.
Duval Gardens is appropriate for travelers who prefer a small property and straightforward room choices.
Hyatt Centric provides on-site dining from casual coffee to a sea-to-table signature restaurant and a poolside bar.
If on-site dining variety matters (from casual to upscale), Hyatt Centric covers multiple needs without leaving the resort.
Duval Gardens listing does not publish an on-site signature restaurant in its supplier facts.
Duval Gardens relies on nearby Duval Street for dining rather than in-house restaurants.
Hyatt Centric has one outdoor pool with cabanas, a whirlpool and nearby small stretch of sand/public beach access.
Hyatt Centric is a waterfront resort with pool facilities and nearby small beach access, useful for families and watersports.
Duval Gardens lists one outdoor pool and highlights 24-hour pool access in its supplier facts.
Duval Gardens offers a simple outdoor pool and close walking access to beaches; pool access hours are unusually noted as 24-hour in the listing.
Hyatt Centric features Jala Spa and a 24-hour fitness center, plus evening options on-site and nearby nightlife.
Hyatt Centric accommodates guests wanting spa services and fitness plus easy access to Old Town nightlife.
Duval Gardens lists nearby spa/health services and highlights being in the center of Duval Street nightlife, while remaining an adults-only property.
Duval Gardens is a good fit if you want immediate access to Duval Street nightlife without on-site large-scale wellness facilities.

Hyatt Centric — family-friendly policies, children's menus and more room types and facilities.

Duval Gardens — an adults-only property that does not admit under-18s and sits on Duval Street.

Hyatt Centric — Four Flamingos plus a poolside bar and waterfront dining options.

Duval Gardens — located at 1317 Duval St, with many attractions and beaches within very short walks.
Hyatt Centric is the family-friendly choice; Duval Gardens is adults-only and does not admit guests under 18.
Hyatt Centric has Jala Spa on site. Duval Gardens’ listing notes a health/beauty spa nearby but does not name an on-site spa.
Duval Gardens sits directly on Duval Street, while Hyatt Centric is steps from Duval Street with quick walking access—both are convenient, but Duval Gardens is literally on the strip.
Yes. Both list one outdoor pool; Duval Gardens’ supplier listing notes 24-hour pool access.
Explore how Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·